So much for writing up each book I read as I finish it. I’ve read probably ten or fifteen books in the past few weeks and all that has made it here are a few quotes. Once again I resolve to do better starting now.
Just finished reading: Midwives by Chris Bohjalin.
Have I read it before: nope.
Shallow or deep: deep.
Worth reading: yes.
Will I read it again: probably not.
How good really: Pretty good. Doesn’t make it to my favorites list, but still, pretty good.
Comments:
The fastest reserve ever. Someone on a mailing list reccomended this book about a month ago. I tried to check it out then but it wasn’t in. It wasn’t in once again when I went to the library a week ago, so I put it on reserve along with a bunch of other books. Five minutes later I went to check out my books and the librarian said “oh, you have a book waiting on the reserve shelf.” In the time it took me to find one last book and make it to the checkout counter it had come in.
The book is about a trial and is told from the point of view of a child (well, teenager) so of course just as soon as I started reading it I thought To Kill a Mockingbird I’m not the only one apparently, after finishing the book I read the quotes on the back and sure enough, one of them compares it to that wonderful novel. This book is good, but it doesn’t live up to Mockingbird. It’s not really fair, anyway, to compare anything to a book that wonderful.
Oh yes, the story. The story is told from the POV of a fourteen year old girl. Her mother is a midwife on trial after she performed a home cesarian on a dead women in her home to save her infant son on a night the phones were out and road conditions made it impossible to get the woman to the hospital. At issue: some people believe the mother was still alive when the midwife cut into her.
It’s a good story and a good book, though there was a point in the middle where I found myself rather bored and wishing the author would hurry on with the story. The beginning and the end were wonderful, and the end was not what I had expected from reading the beginning.
I think that Bohjalian was pretty fair in the handling of the contraversy concerning homebirth. The book was about a homebirth where a woman died, but plenty of evidence in support of homebirth was given in the book.
I really don’t have much to say about this book right now, other than it is worth reading. I only copied one quote from the book, though there were probably several more I should have kept.
As always, if you read this book, please let me know what you think of it.